I present the best shortstop in the American League, perhaps even the majors.
Asdrubal Cabrera of the Cleveland Indians is hitting .312 with an OPS of .919. Although he has no where near as many homers as the league leader (Cabrera has 10 at the moment), his defense sets him apart from anyone at the position.
Will he be voted into the All-Star Game? Probably not. That honor will undeservedly go to an old and broken Derek Jeter, as per usual. He should however receive an invitation to the roster through the managers, one of which is Manny Acta.